Bill Hulet Editor


Here's the thing. A lot of important Guelph issues are really complex. And to understand them we need more than "sound bites" and knee-jerk ideology. The Guelph Back-Grounder is a place where people can read the background information that explains why things are the way they are, and, the complex issues that people have to negotiate if they want to make Guelph a better city. No anger, just the facts.
Showing posts with label Environmental Ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Environmental Ethics. Show all posts

Thursday, October 24, 2019

Public Education: Baby Steps Versus Playing the "Long Game"

Several years ago I was volunteering for a Green Party election campaign and I got "schooled" by a "hip youngster" with a degree in marketing about why it is important to not be what I'd call "punk and plain" about environmental issues during an election campaign. (I have a tendency to go on about unlimited economic growth being the ideology of cancer, among other things.) She told me that she had been taught that the key to effective advertising is to change people's behaviour and that that comes from appealing to them "where they are" instead of "where you'd like them to be".

She used the example of a fairly famous advert from my childhood, one that she said studies had shown did absolutely nothing to actually change people's behaviour. Here it is (ah, the wonders of YouTube!):



(Before we get too far, let me first admit that this video is somewhat racist. It plays to the "magic Indian" trope. This says that the First Nations peoples have some sort of inherent, genetic propensity to being environmentally groovy. While I think a case can be made that at least some of the tribal cultures are more "in tune" with nature, I don't want to give credit to the idea that this is something inherent in their genetic make up---which is clearly as racist as saying that all Chinese Canadians are good at math, and, all Black Canadians "have rhythm". Moreover, there is the whole point that the actor playing the role was actually an Italian-American who had adopted the persona and name of "Iron Eyes Cody". Having said that, I don't think that this invalidates anything I'm going to write after this disclaimer.)

Here's the other advert that her professor compared it to, one that actually is supposed to have made a real difference in how people act.


At the time I hadn't heard about this second ad, I was old, she was young, and I didn't want to get into an argument with someone who had studied marketing. But something about what she had said just didn't "sit right" with me. That was over 10 years ago, but I think I've finally figured out what I didn't like about what she said.

&&&&

Every time an organization creates and promotes a message it is going to have to decide whether it wants to "play the long game" or "seek out the low-hanging fruit". I would argue that our discussion wasn't about whether or not we were going to change people's behaviour, but actually about whether we were playing the long game or seeking after low-hanging fruit. Moreover, I'd suggest that just chasing low-hanging fruit is ultimately self-defeating in politics.

&&&&

On one level, this involves the message you are projecting to the audience. In the case of the "don't mess with Texas" ad, it is simply that you should put the trash in the can, period. The "crying Indian" ad is much more ambitious. It's trying to suggest that there is something inherently wrong with modern industrial society. That's why we have shots of him paddling through harbours with cranes, factories, oil refineries etc in the background. It's also why we have a zero-in on the huge traffic-filled highways before we see a bag of fast-food dumped at his feet. In short, the "crying Indian" ad was a critique of modern, capitalist, industrial society whereas the "don't mess with Texas" one was simply focused on litter.

Also, think about the people who were chosen in each different ad to represent the public viewpoint. In "Don't Mess with Texas", the heroes were two extremely well-paid NFL players. In "the Crying Indian" it was (I've already offered my disclaimers above) a First Nations member---certainly not a person of privilege. So it is a case of putting in the viewpoint of people who have the system working for them, and another who has probably seen nothing but exploitation from it.

The point I'd like readers to meditate upon is that it is always easier to do well in the short term if you have no problem with ignoring the long haul. For example, a government can almost always gin up the economy for a few years with tax cuts---if you don't care about the size of the deficit or the resulting wealth stratification in society. Executives can always increase the dividends they pay stock holders for a few years if they cut their research and development departments, and, avoid investing in new machinery---at the price of having the competition "eat their lunch" ten years down the road. Similarly, a political party can always do better in the short run by pandering to voter's pre-conceived notions than in trying to educate them about important issues---if they don't care about the long-term consequences for society.

And what exactly has been the trajectory of Texas since the "don't mess with Texas" ad first aired? Well, a quick Google search resulted in the following statistic:  Texas is 48th worst out of 50 states in terms of health risks from pollution.  (US News and World Report) (Obviously someone is messing with Texas after all---.)

&&&&

I suspect that at least some of my readers keep meaning to subscribe but never quite get around to doing so. It's not that hard. If you have a credit card (and I know that almost all of you do), all you have to do is sign up on Patreon or PayPal. But here's something new---why not have your community group buy a subscription? Unions, service clubs, charitable institutions---you all benefit from having local news. Why not subscribe? Or even buy an advertisement, for that matter. All sorts of groups used to buy ads in the old paper newspapers---what's stopping you from doing the same thing in the Back-Grounder? 

Drop me an email at thecloudwalkingowl@gmail.com if you want to find out more.
 


&&&&

Both of these advertisements have become "icons" in the American psyche, so it might be useful to see how they have exerted their influence since they were first created.

Here's a clip from The Simpsons that plays on the "crying Indian" ad: 


And here's another advert from Texas that is an out-growth of the original "Don't Mess with Texas" ad: 


I've cherry picked somewhat, but I do think that there is some sort of rough generalization that can be discerned here. But the point I want to make is that almost all pieces of messaging can be divided into two different messages: the foreground and the background.

In the case of the clip from the Simpsons, the foreground message is clearly that there is something profoundly wrong with American society---hence the giant, rat-infested garbage dump. The background message is that native Americans have some deeper appreciation and respect for nature than the average citizen. In the case of the official Texas advert, the foreground message is "don't litter", but the background one is "have respect for the military" and even "we honour our Confederate traditions". (I suspect this last bit is unconscious and came about simply because an existing institution---the Texas Confederate Airforce---helped with the ad. Indeed, the organization realized this fact and in 2002 changed it's name to the "Commemorative Air Force".)

The original advert inspired a whole line of official ads aimed at the "don't mess with Texas" trope. Here is one that is more than a bit "loopy":


Here's one that is a bit more indicative of most of them:



And another official ad that plays on the usual tropes:





The real message of the "don't mess with Texas" ads is that "life is good, happy motoring is good, things are just fine in Texas---just don't toss your trash out the window of your car as you roar down the road on your way to destroying the planet!"

&&&&

In the recent election there were a lot of times that I thought the politicians were obviously pandering to public opinion polls without even attempting to make any sense. Two examples that immediately come to mind were the idiotic policies that the Conservatives and Liberals came up with to make housing more affordable. Scheer announced that he'd loosen the requirements that would allow more people to get a mortgage, and, he'd allow it to be paid off in a maximum 30 years instead of the current 25. Trudeau's offer was to expand the "First-Time Home Buyer Incentive".

Both of these suggestions are flat-out idiotic and would be immediately obvious as such to anyone who hadn't flunked first year economics. That's because they don't actually increase the number of houses being built, just make it easier for everyone to borrow money in order to buy one. If they were implemented, they'd just increase the cost of housing, and channel more money out of home-owner's pockets and into the banks.

Both the Conservatives and Liberals had to have known this fact. But the leaders looked at the polling numbers and decided that they had to say something that sounded like they were concerned about housing affordability. As such, both Scheer and Trudeau were deciding to "make baby steps" and "pander to people's preconceived notions" rather than try to educate voters about the real reasons why housing is so damned expensive. They were following the "don't mess with Texas" route instead of the "crying Indian" one.

They thought that they had to do this to win the election. But the problem is that by pandering to the ignorance of voters, they were making it that much harder to get them to accept a more reasonable policy later on down the road. If you keep telling people "there's no reason to make hard choices---it's all just peachy the way it is", it may be surprising, but it's true none-the-less, that a lot of them will actually believe it. And if you turn around and tell them something different at a later date---like "if you want affordable housing you are simply going to have to accept living in small homes in higher density neighbourhoods"---they are not going to be happy to hear it. In effect, every time parties do the "easy thing" and suggest that all people need to do is "make baby steps", they are dramatically limiting their ability to tell voters the hard truth at some time in the future.

&&&&

This problem has been identified a long time ago. Henry David Thoreau once opined
"There are a thousand people hacking at the branches of evil to one striking at the root."
Henry was no fool, he knew what was important.
Henry David Thoreau, Public Domain image by Geo. F. Parlow.
Public Domain Image c/o the Wiki Commons.
And that's the ultimate problem with taking "baby steps" in our messaging about important public policy issues: they only strike at the branch of problems while leaving their roots still strong and vigorous.

&&&&

Furthermore, I say onto you the Climate Emergency must be dealt with!

Wednesday, July 3, 2019

Mike Schreiner Talks About Capitalism

The second part of my interview with our MPP deals with some of the complexities and "nitty gritty" of how he sees our society can make a transition towards a sustainable society. Leadership doesn't just entail telling us where we should be going, it also involves navigating the pitfalls and traps set out to derail our migration to the "promised land".

Mike Schreiner, Guelph's member at Queen's Park.
Image from the GPO website.

&&&&

Hulet:  I did some articles about solid waste a while back and was horrified by the upfront and brazen way some businesses were trying to confuse the public and sabotage the Ontario government's attempts to control solid waste. One example were public relation campaigns aimed at people who use coffee pods to tell them that they were recyclable and compostable---they're not. Another example involved businesses spending lots of money to install computerized cash registers that separated out disposal fees from the "cost" of the product---instead of just burying the "eco-fee" in the cost of the product. They also put out advertisements  that didn't include the eco-fees in the listed price---which punished competitors who didn't separate the fees. And---just to add a cherry on the top---got caught charging too much! Another example was where the Stewardship Councils set up by the province to reduce solid waste simply ignored the reason why they were created in the first place and instead produced a report that suggested recycling could be cheaper if garbage collection was privatized.  

In light of all this "jiggery-pokery", I have a question for you. How do you think the Ontario government would be able to "house train" business? The system I refer to above---eco-fees and Stewardship Ontario---were attempts by both Conservative and Liberal government to use "market mechanisms" to make solid waste reduction part of their design criteria. Instead, they just played political games and sabotaged the system. You're a business person, how would you deal with this Tom Foolery?
Schreiner:  Yeah, good question. 
&&&&

Indeed, this is a very big issue.

It isn't just about solid waste issues either. Capitalism just doesn't play nice with either science or the public good. And contrary to what many people might think, there is almost always no government agency who's job it is to make sure that businesses "do the right thing". Instead, more often there are rules that say that businesses should hire consultants to do the research and then send the results to a government agency to look at. And, as a recent article in the National Observer points out, there is a conflict of interest inherent in that relationship that can result in pressure being put on researchers to "fudge" the results in a way that benefits the company at the expense of public interest.

One of the very first articles I ever wrote---for the Ontarion, in 1978---was about an investigation that was then going on in the USA into a scientific business named "Industrial Bio-Test Laboratories". It turned out that this company had done the "safety tests" on a huge range of different chemicals for various corporations and had often "fudged" the results in order to make sure that things got on the market, whether they were really safe or not. This included some of the most widely used farm chemicals, ones that my family had routinely used when I was a child. I was enraged to find out that scientists would lie about how safe something was in order to protect their jobs---and that the government had set up a system that was based on this insane conflict of interest. But as the article in the National Observer points out, this problem continues to this day.

Schreiner is just talking about the use of market-based solutions to control large amounts of relatively benign waste. But exactly the same issues apply to the greater issue of how businesses interact with any government regulations. That is, they have a tendency to take them over. Indeed, the phenomenon is so common that it has it's own name in academic research: "regulatory capture". So when you read what follows, remember that some of the issues that Mike identifies don't just apply to cutting down on solid waste, but also things like protecting salmon spawning beds and keeping toxic chemicals out of the water supply.

&&&&
One of the things is to design "rules of the game" that enable businesses to profit from "doing a good thing" and have enough "sticks" in place to push them along to do the right thing.  
Part of the problem with the way a lot of market mechanisms are designed---cap-and-trade is an example, Stewardship Ontario is another---is we make the market mechanisms so complicated, and so dependent on industry running them that they don't actually become market mechanisms.  
I think that this happens because government is afraid of "laying it on the line" with people , or, being brutally honest with people who try to hide things. So Stewardship Ontario was a way to try to hide waste management fees and costs. Cap-and-trade is a way to try to hide carbon pricing. 
One of the reasons I've always promoted individual producer responsibility is to get away from this whole industry-led bureaucratic apparatus like you had with Stewardship Ontario. You just say "industry, you're responsible for the cost of the waste you produce" and those businesses that don't produce that waste will have a competitive advantage in the marketplace.  
&&&&

Schreiner is raising an important point here, one that readers should understand. The current system we have with regard to solid waste (amongst a great many other things) is "industry-wide". Businesses form groups---like the "Stewardship Councils"---and they make collective decisions about how they should deal with a generic problem, such as solid waste. That's where regulatory capture takes place. "Individual producer responsibility" is very different. Mike's suggesting that instead of assigning a cost for a generic thing, such as "litter", and asking for the entire packaging industry to come up with a solution (eg: the Stewardship Ontario model), each individual business should have their own individual price associated with their part of the litter problem.

Consider the following scenario. After a particularly "festive and vibrant" Friday night in the city of Guelph, the downtown early-morning cleanup crews decided to do an audit of what gets left on the sidewalks---what percentage of chicken bones, styrofoam clamshells, half-eaten poutine, etc. Using this information, the city then ascertains what percentage of the clean up budget has been spent cleaning up the mess left by customers of which particular business. Then each of those establishments gets a clean up bill, but the amount varies widely based on what percentage of the mess came from their particular business. If this were done, the business models that create the most mess might find out that when the price of cleaning up is subtracted, they actually lose money. At that point, solid waste becomes part of the "design criteria" when each owner is creating a business plan.

The two points he is emphasizing are that businesses need to be individually identified (through the garbage audit), and, there should also to be significant individualized penalties (ie: the variable clean up bill) assigned to individual companies that will cause enough harm that it forces them to change how they do things. 

&&&&
From my perspective, the way to sell this to tax payers---and the government hasn't done a very good job doing this---is to be really clear that you are paying for waste right now in your property taxes. A huge portion of property taxes are dealing with waste, and waste management. So essentially, you as a tax payer are footing the bill and giving businesses an incentive to reduce the waste they produce.  
People mention "tax payer revolts"---I think people should revolt against having to pay for industry's wasteful practices. If we actually had full individual producer responsibility laws that, they would produce the incentives to reduce waste.
&&&&

This raises a good question. Just how much does Guelph spend on solid waste?

It's not a simple thing to answer. If you've never looked at a city budget, you might be surprised how complex it is. That's because it is possible to organize information in a lot of different ways. For example, many things the city manages are not paid for through taxes, but instead through revenue. The fees we pay for water and sewer, for example, are not taxes but monthly business fees---just like electricity. That means that this doesn't get included in the "tax-paid" part of the budget. More revenue comes through federal and provincial grants. Also, the budget separates out capital expenditures (eg: new buildings) from day-to-day costs (eg: paying the janitor that cleans the floors). As well, much of the budget is designed to aggregate things like labour costs under one heading instead of separating them out into separate departments.

Topping all of this off is the fact that budgets are obviously written in a hurry by people who's primary skill set isn't being able to express themselves clearly and precisely to the general public. Municipal bureaucrats also speak their own bizarre language that can be tremendously hard to understand. To cite one example, I spent quite a few minutes trying to figure out exactly what a "growth vehicle" is in one section---I think it might be a new garbage truck, but I could be wrong.

Solid waste can be particularly thorny to develop a figure for. Consider the following complications:

  • a significant fraction of the waste produced is dealt with by commercial and industrial institutions that have their own private solid waste contractors that by-pass the municipal system
  • there are user fees for people who drop off their own materials---so it isn't all tax-funded
  • recycled materials are sold on an extremely volatile spot market that means that from week to week the city has a wildly varying revenue stream that they add to the operating budget
  • Stewardship Ontario is already paying a significant fraction of the operating budgets of municipal waste systems
  •  the cost of "dealing with waste" isn't just a result of dealing with garbage that's been placed in bins and waiting at the curb---it also involves people in other departments (and other parts of the budget) doing things like picking up litter 

I tried to come up with a number for Guelph, but gave up after fighting with the budget document for about an hour. It isn't that important to the issue at hand---especially as Schreiner is a Member of the Provincial Parliament (MPP) instead of a city councilor. Suffice it to say, the number is significant. But the problem with coming up with a real number is part of that "transparency" thing that our MPP is talking about.

I could be argued that trying to figure out what particular business creates what particular fraction of environmental destruction would be far too much work. That's generally the reaction when people propose things like that. From the point-of-view of management there is some truth to this. But with modern computer technology it really shouldn't be that hard to do the odd audit for things like garbage pick up to find out exactly where the garbage is coming from, and charge businesses accordingly.

Where the real problems would lie, I suspect, would be in the realm of governance. Businesses are parts of interconnected webs of commerce and regulation. Create a new regulation on one node in this structure, and results propagate across the entire system. For example---to continue with the example of downtown pickup after an night of "rich and vibrant" activity in the downtown core---some of the businesses that create the filth are franchises. That means you aren't just dealing with the individual business, but the head office. Even if you have a rare independently-owned and operated business, they often have contractual agreements that lock them into buying specific products in exchange for a better price. Margins can be very tight, and a slight disturbance in "the Force" can make the difference between success and failure.

The old law saying that all beer in Ontario had to be sold in exactly the same type of bottle was a wonderful example of how a sustainable society could be organized. Yet it fell apart after Canada liberalized trade laws with other countries. It was simply against the law for the province to legislate packaging that seemed to give an "unfair advantage" to locally-produced beer. It is still against the law, and I would suggest that similar problems would come into play if Ontario tried to bring in "independent producer responsibility" and tried to make it the foundation of government policy.

The reason why it could work in the past but was legislated out of existence was because of a profound change in technology that led to a profound change in commerce. I once met an old economics prof who told me that when he was young he had an exam question that asked "Why will there never be a national beer company?" The point was that beer was a heavy, low-price product. That mean that shipping it thousands of miles would inevitably add a significant fraction to the cost, which would stop people from buying their suds from anyone else but local brewers.

It was exactly the same with several commodities: beer, soda pop, milk. This mean that there were no national bottlers, which meant that consumers were close to the bottling plants. This made it easy to have returnable bottle laws. The trucks were already going to the stores and homes to drop off the milk, pop, and, beer---why not have them pick up the empties and bring them back at the same time? But once the interstate highways, giant transport trucks, and, cheap diesel fuel came along, you could ship heavy, low price commodities long distances and still stay in business. (Bottled water is simply the latest example of this general process.) All the local soda pop producers, dairies, and, breweries went under, and so did the refillable bottle laws with them. There was a fundamental change in the economic ecosystem, and the laws followed suit.

This isn't to say that individual producer responsibility is a bad idea. It isn't even to say that it shouldn't or can't be done. What I am pointing out, however, is that it is a radical thing to suggest and do. It's also important to remember that governments do radical things all the time. For example, the excellent road system that allows transport trucks to move beer across the continent didn't exist at the end of WW2 (that was a conflict run on railroads.) The government decided to spend a lot of money creating them and in the process dramatically changed various aspects of the existing economy. In the same way, creating a system of "independent producer responsibility" would also be a big, radical, disruptive thing for the government to do---but it could do it. And it would also make radical changes to the economy. 

&&&&

I recently went to a panel discussion where an academic and Adam Donaldson joined several people who'd worked at the old Guelph Mercury to discuss local news. One thing that I kinda gagged on was the nostalgic blather about the "halcyon days" of working for the old Merc. I was an outside observer of the paper since the late 1980s, and by the time it folded it was a wan shadow of itself. And most of that couldn't be blamed on the Internet or Google---it had been looted by various "media empires" long before they came along.

The event did get me thinking about what this blog is all about, though. I'm obviously not doing straight reporting. Indeed, even when I try to just do traditional reporting---like this interview with our local MPP---things quickly degenerate into something else. The thing is, however, I would feel like I was only doing part of the job if I just hammered out quotes from an interview. I want to explain context. And that involves looking up facts and expanding the argument as best I can so the implications become explicit for the reader. I can only assume that that's not something that is taught or encouraged at journalism school---because so few reporters ever do it.


That means that I'm trying to do something more than just recreate the sort of reportage that you used to get from the Mercury---even before the junk bond artists looted it. If you think that this is a good thing, then why not subscribe through Patreon or PayPal? 

&&&&

Hulet: So it's not just the fees, it's the transparency as well?
Schreiner: It's the transparency and the simplicity. Part of the problem with things like Stewardship Ontario was that it was a bureaucratic entity that we just pay some money to so we don't want to think about solid waste as a business---and you guys just minimize the amount of fees we're paying. 
And that "quote", is a "market mechanism"?????  That's not a market mechanism. [You can hear the disgust in Schreiner's voice.]
Take Tim Hortons as an example. I don't want to pick on Tim Hortons---I will because I do a lot of roadside clean-up and Tim Horton's cups are one of the things we pick up the most. If Tim Hortons actually had to pay the cost of picking-up all those cups, they'd figure out a way to reduce the number of cups that go into the waste stream. But right now they have no industry incentive to do that---they just give all that money to Stewardship Ontario and don't worry about it. 
&&&&

I wrote earlier that I couldn't find a number for how much the city spends on solid waste, but I did find one number on one particular website.

This advertisement comes from the "Adopt A Highway Inc.".
Image used under the "Fair Use" copyright provision.
We've all seen the "Adopt a Highway" signs, but I think it's somewhat useful to stop and think about what is going on. People volunteer to pick up trash that was created by businesses as part of their business model. Isn't picking up the resulting garbage the same thing as if the local restaurant asked for volunteers to wash dishes and wait on tables so they didn't have to pay hired staff?

I suspect that the difference is that somewhere in our minds most of us have bought into the idea that that it was an individual "choice" for a certain segment of the population to throw garbage out of their cars---and you can't blame the business for that, can you? But maybe you can. If all human decisions simply came down to a conscious personal choice (eg: I freely choose to throw this garbage out the window---fully aware of the implications of that choice for all and sundry), why do we have an advertising industry?

Here's a classic television advert that I believe makes my point. What exactly is it trying to tell the public---that their brand of car is the best for mowing down British soldiers? I'd posit instead that it's suggesting that there's something intrinsic to the American psyche that muscle cars appeals to. Driving fast without having to think about hitting wildlife or creating a climate disaster is what it means to be "free". So if you are a patriotic American, buy one of our autos and "stick it to" those elites who want the government to regulate all the "fun" out of your life. 



Here's another example. This Tim Horton's advert appeals to the emotions and myths that Canadians like to tell about themselves. The immigrant dad brought ideas about life over from the "old country" that he tried to impose on his son. But because of way he was welcomed into his adopted country (the white guy giving him a coffee when he first came into the rink to see his son play), he "came around" and adopted "Canadian" values.


The important thing to realize is that you are rarely going to see someone argue that saving the planet is a bad idea. What instead happens is that that ideal gets "drowned out" by some other message. For example, American "FREEDOM!!!!!", or, Canadian "Can't we all just be nice to each other?"

Several times I've been told by professional advertisers that all they do is "help consumers choose between brands", and that their pitches cannot be blamed for having a bigger influence on society. But that is patent nonsense. Businesses build themselves around a specific message such as "convenience" or "caring", and this results in mountains of unnecessary crap.  And it's also patent nonsense to think that a restaurant who's business model is based on maximizing convenience while totally ignoring the environmental consequences---and sending off people in their cars with bushels of trash---has no responsibility for those who take the next logical step and just throw said trash out the window of their speeding death wagon while they look for British soldiers to run over.

This is such a "thing" that Family Guy even did a hilarious fake ad that lampooned the way businesses create ridiculous products that only appeal to our emotions and make absolutely no sense at all. (When I worked at the University I used to have to throw out heaps of sad veggies and fruit that well-meaning event organizers would order---and which often never got eaten---because a) food means you care, and, b) we all know people don't eat enough fruit and veggies, and, c) ultimately most people don't want to eat fruit and veggies at meetings.)



&&&&
I think things like re-instituting bottle deposit return programs is an example of that. I think the Brewer's retail has something like a 98% recapture rate---because people have a nickle or dime incentive to take their bottle back. Unbelievable what a little incentive like that can do to reduce waste. 
&&&&

I fear that Schreiner is being a bit optimistic saying that the Brewer's Retail is hitting a 98% recapture rate. The figure I found was 80%, which is still pretty good. It does raise the question, however, about what is going to happen with this bottle return system if Doug Ford and his merry band of "enablers" break up the existing "Beer Store" near monopoly. Will every convenience store and grocery be willing to take on the job of paying out deposits and collecting beer bottles and cans, plus wine and liquor bottles too?

This is the nub of the issue. What we call "free market capitalism" is a very strange thing. Contrary to the propaganda that people get force-fed from a variety of sources, it is not "free". In a totally "free" situation, businesses quickly make arrangements to fix prices. As the patron saint of capitalism, Adam Smith, observed:
People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices. (Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations, Book One, Chapter X, Part II, p. 152.)
A marketplace that's controlled by monopolies and cartels isn't really "free". The reason why we have something like a free market is through government intervention that creates a modicum of real competition.

One example of this is the way the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) forces Bell Canada and the cable companies to provide bandwidth to independent Internet Service Providers (ISPs), so you can get decent service at a reasonable price. If they didn't, the only people you could buy access to the internet from would be Bell and Rogers---who would probably charge even more than they do now. (I'm a happy Teksavvy customer.)

So what Schreiner is saying is that society needs to expand the regulatory oversight of government to create a new "niche" where freedom can "invade" the marketplace---such as when the CRTC forced the "wire owners" to allow some new competition in the ISP market. As I pointed out in my hypothetical example of the downtown trash audit, there would have to be government mechanisms put into place before we could create a genuine system of "individual producer responsibility", that would force businesses to make environmental sustainability part of the "bottom line". Please note something interesting here. People often talk about "market mechanisms" versus "regulations" when it comes to developing public policy solutions, but as I've suggested above, you can't really have a market mechanism (or a "free" market at all) without introducing some pretty stringent regulations first. 

&&&&

This is probably a good place to stop and let the reader mull things over. I think this post---probably more than any other I've done---shows how complicated government policy can be. Because of the practicalities of the job, politicians have to be very brief in their pronouncements: the ten second sound bite on the news, a couple minutes at the doorstep, five minutes at an "all candidates debate". But still, they are dealing with profoundly complex issues. We voters should at least understand the difficulties people like Schreiner are labouring under as they attempt to do their job.

&&&&

Furthermore, I say to you---the climate emergency must be dealt with!

Friday, June 7, 2019

Post-Denialism, or, Can There Be an Environmental Morality?

During this Spring's floods I noticed something really quite remarkable about our dear Premier. Unlike other Conservatives, he's simply given up on trying to deny the existence of the climate emergency.


Instead, what he does is confuse people about what policies his government is pursuing. That means that he can cut provincial funding that is designed to deal with flooding, while at the same time looking like he really cares in photo ops. He can also say that Ontario is doing a great job in reducing carbon emissions but without pointing out that he rode to power by smearing the Liberal electricity policy. (You know, the policy that actually allowed Ontario to become the first major jurisdiction in North America to eliminate their coal-fired generators.)  He also ignores the fact that he has eliminated Ontario's participation in the cap-and-trade system designed to further cut emissions.

This is an interesting development because it's an example of something sociologist Keith Kahn-Harris calls "post-denialism".

You may have heard the famous quote that says "Hypocrisy is the compliment that vice pays to virtue". This means that one only feels the need to be a hypocrite if one feels ashamed---or at least believes that one is expected to feel ashamed---to do a particular bad thing. For Kahn-Harris, he would paraphrase that quote from Francois de La Rochefoucauld as "denialism is the homage people pay to whatever they are denying".

Keith Kahn-Harris, image from his Twitter Feed.
Used under the "Fair-Use" copyright provision. 

As Kahn-Harris says, the key to understanding something like Holocaust denial is that the person doesn't really believe that the mass murder of Jews never happened. What he really wants to say is that their murder was a good thing and that the Third Reich was a great idea. The denier doesn't say this, however, because that is a profoundly unpopular point of view. So instead, he creates some sort of convoluted and lame argument that the Holocaust never happened. This creates a semblance of intellectual legitimacy that he and his fellow apologists for the NAZIs can hide behind.

In much the same way, people have traditionally attempted to deny the reality of the climate emergency because they had to "pay homage" to the fact that most people would admit that runaway climate change would be a very bad thing. But Doug Ford seems to have gotten to the point where he can admit that climate change exists and is "a thing"---but he just doesn't care. If he was alone in this, I wouldn't really care all that much. But he is surrounded by a political party filled with "enablers" who allow him to continue with his policies. And beneath them, there are lots of voters who supported him and gave him a majority government. What's going on here? Don't these people actually care about their children's future?

&&&&

I found out something this week. It turns out that you don't have to go through Patreon in order to make a monthly payment to "The Guelph-Back-Grounder", instead you can also do it directly through PayPal. (Thanks to Kathleen for not only being so awesome, but finding a new way to do it!) This means that you can pay directly in Canadian currency. Whatever way you choose to subscribe, however, it is much appreciated.

&&&&

The important thing to understand is that morality---what we call "right" or "wrong"---is an enormously complex issue. Unfortunately, you wouldn't know this if your only experience with moral decision-making was based on the institutions that govern our lives. Let me illustrate with an example.

Our criminal justice system is based on the notion that each individual goes through life freely choosing all their behaviours using a totally dispassionate cost-benefit analysis. Everyone---no matter what their personal history or genetic make-up---has exactly the same ability to rationally do a cost-benefit analysis of all their actions, all the time. This means that if someone does a criminal act, they do so fully aware of the consequences of being caught and freely chooses to do it. That means, that if someone chooses to break the law they can be deterred from doing so in future by punishing them with a jail term. And after they have received that sentence, they will realize that the price of getting caught and punished outweighs the benefit of committing the crime. This means that everyone who is caught and punished never commits a crime ever again.


Of course, the reality is totally different. But why?

To understand that, I'd suggest that people look at the history of criminal justice in our culture. Let's start with the gladiatorial combats in the Roman Arena. Most of the people who fought and died there were convicted criminals or prisoners of war. And the most common sorts of fights were ritual reenactments of early battles between the Romans and other cultures. As such, they were theatrical attempts to get the audience to feel what it means to be a member of Roman society. Because people are actually fighting for their lives, and, participants are going to actually die, it was very easy to become emotionally engaged with the spectacle. (Incidentally, this is why popular movies have lots of sex and violence---it's a short cut for directors to get audiences to pay attention.)

In much the same way, Anglo-Saxon "jurisprudence" often consisted of trial by combat or ordeal. The former consisted of a ritual duel where combatants representing two different sides would fight using a variety of weapons in a specified way. The idea was that "God" would reveal who was right according to who won. A trial by ordeal involved one person choosing to do some specifically painful act---such as grasping a hot piece of metal. The idea would be God would reveal guilt or innocence by whether or not the man could perform the task or would survive the consequences.

In both of these cases, the important issue is that a "combat" has been done and it was done theatrically to appeal to the emotions of an audience. We still have such a thing in our modern system. Instead of having two people going after each other with swords or pole axes, we have lawyers jousting with words. And instead of asking people to grab red hot metal bars, we expect them to dump all their wealth on the balance in the form of lawyer's fees and submit to years of litigation. If they have the "guts" and "stamina" to handle this ordeal, they may have been proved to be in-the-right.

In the past people enjoyed the theatrical event of executions. In our more modern era people are restricted to purging their emotions through dramatic recreations---witness the enormous number of crime-based television shows. In addition, our politicians use the punishment of the guilty to "whip" their followers into a frenzy of support, and, the media use the same spectacle to get maximum "clicks". (Check out this example of the Conservatives and CBC doing a ritual dance around the corpse of a little girl.)

  

In effect, our criminal justice system is not primarily about either morality or even changing human behaviour. Instead, it is a type of theatre designed primarily to arouse and channel people's emotions in ways that strengthen ordinary citizen's support for the various institutions of the state: the police, the government, political parties, and, the media. Criminals and victims are pretty much not more than sock puppets that these different "powers and principalities" manipulate to create the "passion-play" that keeps our society working.

&&&&

What has this got to do with the climate emergency? Well, I'd argue that whether or not we destroy the planet is a moral issue. Depending on how you construct your ethical worldview, it is either a crime against future human beings, or, it is a crime against the entire ecosystem. Either way, it is a very, very, bad thing to do. And yet, lots of people seem to be treating the whole issue as just another "ho hum" event. Why?

I'd suggest that it's because morality only "works" for most people if they can channel their emotions into it. And the way our society codifies and controls these emotions is through creating elaborate "passion plays"---just like our criminal justice system. And for many people, their emotions have already been "captured" by other things. It's like a type of love. We don't just love everyone, instead most of us have to love a specific person or persons: our partners, our children, our extended family. If we really stretch it, we can love an institution---like the church or the military, or, something more tribal, like our ethnic identity or country. But very few people can love everyone and everything. That sort of thing we may pay lip service to, but in practice it's reserved for "saints".

In our society I'd suggest that a lot of people who are interested in the conservative way of looking at the world have had their emotional attention "caught" by a specific definition of "freedom". This can be small "boutique" freedoms like the "right to bear arms", or, a strange type of religious freedom that involves inflicting your views on others. But more commonly, it boils down to an emotional attachment to "the free market" or a personal identification as "someone who pays their own way".

My experience with a lot of business people is that they often see what they are doing as some sort of "greater calling" that makes them feel like they are participating in something noble and good. I believe that this is related to why so many young people are so attached to the writings of Ayn Rand. As teenagers we are genetically programmed to separate ourselves from our parents and develop our own personalities and worldview. (Just like when kittens are weaned they go through a stage where they are programmed to wander great distances in order to find their own "territory".) For adolescents going through this phase, many of us feel that we are like the characters of her novels---great men and women who are working to create something good and noble by pursuing our own particular drives and ambitions, but who are thwarted by a society that keeps trying to keep them from doing what they want. Unfortunately, a significant fraction of the population never grows out of this adolescent phase and doesn't develop any sort of personal sense of responsibility towards others and the common good.

If you want to understand how these people view themselves and their ideals, take a look at the following YouTube clip from "The Fountain Head". If you think, as I do, that the dialogue sounds pretty lame, just remember that when I was younger I thought it was profound. And generations of idealistic young people have gone through a "phase" of also thinking that it's profound. (Heck, the "prog-rock" band Rush built a huge following with their albums praising Ayn Rand.)


If you have really bought into this ideal of total freedom divorced from any responsibility to other people, then the climate crisis sounds like an insane fever dream. Any program that involves everyone pulling together to learn to live more lightly on the earth sounds like a totalitarian nightmare that should be fought tooth and nail---no matter what the cost.

Another conservative "passion play" involves the glorification of self-reliance. This is the pride that right-wing conservatives feel when they are able to "get the job done" even though it is hard. Take a look at this truck advertisement and see how it glorifies the stoicism of "hard working American men" (I hadn't remembered the guy with the bandaged eye or the fellow in a wheelchair lifting himself up with a block and tackle before I looked at it again.)


If you've been raised to glorify self-reliance and stoic acceptance of "the way it is", then any attempt to suggest that society should give the disadvantaged "a leg up" or that there should be some attempt to right past wrongs, is just "queue jumping".  And adding environmental protection to the "design criteria" is just "making things needlessly harder". Both of these things are the ultimate sins in the stoic, self-reliant worldview.

From what I can see, people like Doug Ford and his supporters have their own set of morality that is "clogging" their ability to understand the moral imperative that we need to collectively do something about the climate emergency. That is what has fueled climate denialism for decades. That's why Ford can stand in the midst of terrible flooding, admit that it is probably the result of climate change, and, still work to sabotage any attempt to prevent future disasters. It's simply that he thinks it would be immoral (ie: opposed to Ayn Rand's understanding of "freedom" or a Chevvy truck commercial's vision of "self-reliance") to do so. 

&&&&

I would suggest that this is the real backdrop to climate denialism, just as support for the NAZI agenda is what really motivates Holocaust denial. And Dr. Kahn-Harris would argue that both groups have increasingly dropped denialism because they believe that the recent world-wide success of right-wing populism--Donald Trump in the USA, Brexit in the UK, and, Ford in Ontario---has destroyed the last vestiges of the post-WWII consensus about what is "decent and proper" in public discourse. This allows people to come out of the woodwork to declare that "the Jews will not replace us" and "climate change is causing flooding and forest fires---but we're not going to do anything to stop it because that would interfere with the free market".  That's what Kahn-Harris means when he says we are entering into the period of "post-denialism".

Oddly enough, Dr. Kahn-Harris thinks that post-denialism is a good thing. In his opinion once people really understand what is going on, a lot of "enablers" will gag and quickly drop their support. (After all, the moral universe of radical freedom and stoic self-reliance is pretty lame if you put even casual thought into them.) They want their children to actually have decent lives and for the climate not to go totally berzerk. Popular opinion in Ontario would seem to support this hypothesis. According to the latest poll numbers I see:
Among decided and leaning voters, the Liberals were at 39.9% support, the NDP at 24.2%, the PCs at 22.4% and the Greens at 12%.
I can only hope that this trend continues and that the entire political class learns a lesson from it.

&&&&

Furthermore, I say to you---climate change must be dealt with!