Bill Hulet Editor


Here's the thing. A lot of important Guelph issues are really complex. And to understand them we need more than "sound bites" and knee-jerk ideology. The Guelph Back-Grounder is a place where people can read the background information that explains why things are the way they are, and, the complex issues that people have to negotiate if they want to make Guelph a better city. No anger, just the facts.
Showing posts with label reason. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reason. Show all posts

Thursday, October 14, 2021

Dream Well!!!!!

I have spent the last couple weeks looking a the alternative social media sites Gab and Bitchute---which are functionally copies of Facebook and Youtube, respectively. The only real difference is that they don't censor content if it's out-and-out lies or designed to foster hatred against groups of people. As such, they are where most of the people banned off the mainstream social media end up. It's been a bit of an eye-opener.  

It's a bit of a fire hose, so I won't attempt to describe everything I saw. Instead, I'll try to focus on a couple posts that I think will give my readers a feel for what I saw. I'm going to be a bit sparing about what I post because I've had problems in the past with Google yanking images that they deemed "unacceptable". There's supposed to be an exception for educational purposes, but my experience is that the artificial intelligence cannot tell the difference and if you appeal the odds are that I will never be able to get in touch with a real human being that I can explain things to.  

One of several odd posts I saw contained the following.


This purports to be a photo of a living, metallic wire that a "doctor" removed from a soldier who'd been injected with one of the COVID-19 vaccines. 

Here's a diagnosis from the same doctor about the soldier.

And, a prescription

The thing to understand about the above is what "detox" means in the "alternative medicine" community. It generally isn't the orthodox medicine treatment known as "chelation therapy", which is a rarely used, potentially dangerous treatment for various types of metal poisoning. Instead, it's usually a vague, new-age regime that generally involves a patient spending a lot of money on expensive products that don't do much at all. Quackwatch identifies several common types of "detox" that range from "colonic irrigation" (what our grandparents called an "enema"), through treatments that promote sweating, to some form of pseudo-chelation therapy. 

&&&&

There are a lot of people who publish opinion pieces on the Web and in legacy media. Unfortunately, a lot of them just pull nonsense out of their butts and rant. I like to think that I'm different in that I put a lot of time and effort into researching everything I write. But that takes a lot of time and effort. If you like what I write---and you can afford it---why not buy a subscription or toss something in the tip jar? (Thanks Anthony for being so awesome!) Paypal and Patreon make it easy to do.

&&&& 

There's a second video from Stew Peters that builds on this theme and takes it into X Files territory. I tried to put up an excerpt that showed the insanity, but Youtube's artificial intelligence is incapable of making a distinction between someone who is putting something up to trick people versus using it educate people so they are less likely to get tricked. As a result, you are just going to have to believe me when I describe what they are talking about. (I know, but we live in an imperfect world---get used to it. I have.)

Peters is interviewing a woman by the name of Carrie Madej. (She says she's a doctor, but I'm reticent to call her that given what says in this interview.) In the video he shows some black and white, slightly out-of-focus pictures that look remarkably just like the sort of fuzzy images that I used to see with a cheap compound microscope when I was a kid.


Just for comparison's sake, here's an image I found from an American Public Broadcasting System article on microfiber plastic pollution that looks remarkably similar.

Image from This New York River Dumps Millions of Fabric Microfibers into the Ocean Daily.




The next image is something that Ms Madej became very concerned about. That's because she said it had tentacles, was lifting itself off the slide----"it appeared to be self-aware" and "it knows we were watching it". (How she could infer any of this from a blurred image on a compound microscope is beyond me.)


Here's an example of the sort of weird stuff you can find in just a drop of pond water and see under a microscope. It's a water hydra, recorded from a much better microscope than the one that was used to take the pictures on this dumb show. It's something that elementary school teachers routinely show children to get them to realize how complex the world is and how little our "common sense" prepares us to understand it. 

Image from Larval Behavioral, Morphological Changes, and Nematocyte Dynamics During Settlement of Actinulae of Tubularia mesembryanthemum, Allman 1871 (Hydrozoa: Tubulariidae).

Using the above two pictures plus some others of equally dubious value, she describes them as being evidence of:

  • "an injectable computing system"
  • "super conducting material"
  • "self-assembly, things were growing"
  • "metallic fragments"
  • "tentacles"
  • "graphene-like structures"
  • "sticky glue-like substance that would be considered a hydro-gel"
  • "nano-lipids"

&&&&

Of course this is all nonsense. But it raises the important question "what are these people thinking?" The first thing to remember is that "Dr." Madej is using "technobabble" to confound the viewer. The term comes from Star Trek where writers would inject some sort of baffle-gab into the conversation between characters that would suggest some sort of pseudo-scientific reason for the magic that the plot needs to explain the crisis or save the day.
 


In the case of The Stew Peters Show, the guest---Carrie Madej---is using the con-man's version of the "Gish gallop" to dump a load of bullshit on the viewer so it will over-load whatever doubts she might have about any one particular part of it. (That's the same sort of maneuvor that a confidence trickster used separate me from $60 a couple weeks ago.)

Is she a "wiseguy" doing this on purpose to separate "suckers" from their money? Perhaps. (Quacks charge good money for all those detox treatments.) But that doesn't necessarily mean that she is aware of what she is doing. As I explained in my article a while back titled Human Parasites, natural selection can create different types of populations within a given species. It might be that evolution has created a specific type of human personality---should we call them "homo flakyensus"?---that instinctively spew this sort of nonsense. In that case Carrie Madej really does believe in this stuff and makes a living off it in just the same way a real doctor makes a living off what he does.   

Whatever is going on the heads of people who create this stuff, we also have to account for those who eat it up. I think that this is where the Trekkie idea of "techno-babble" may offer a suggestion. Writers insert this stuff into scripts not to annoy scientists, but rather to create a simulation of reality in a situation that is totally unreal. It's part of telling a convincing story.

And link together enough convincing stories and you end up with what writers call a "mythos". Star Trek has an extremely well-developed mythos that includes heroes (Zephran Cochran), villains (the Borg), political organizations (the Federation), an economic system (as near as I can tell, utopian Communism), and so forth. The Star Trek mythos is so appealing to people that television studios have repeatedly created new shows about it and fans have devoted a great deal of energy into making it a "hobby" through cosplay.

People organize their lives around different mythical systems. In my case, I've constructed a rationalist system that merges parts of Daoism with the scientific Enlightenment of Europe. Many others live in a world that brings together Christianity and Laissez-Faire Capitalism. There are a lot of others. In the case of anti-vaxxers, I think that they have created a mythos that draws from a great many different sources. 

One of them is a profound fear of modern technology fueled by a profound ignorance about how things actually work. You can see this in Madej's belief that scientists are able to inject something into a person's arm that would be able to create metallic filaments and a microscopic yet somehow sentient creature. This doesn't require an evil government conspiracy, but rather an X-Files alien alliance. Only someone who has no understanding of what modern technology can and cannot do would come up with this fantasy.

Another part of this worldview is fear that the government will take away people's "freedom". Again and again Stew Peters ranted about the government "forcing vaccines into people's arms". 

&&&&

Why are these mythos I'm talking about so important? I recently watched a video by Rebecca Watson where the issue of motivated reasoning came up. This is the idea that a large part of what people call "rational decision-making" is actually human consciousness creating excuses for decisions that have already been made emotionally. As she explained it, she used the metaphor of a monkey riding a tiger. 

I found this image being used by a Thai Restaurant, so I assumed they wouldn't mind if I copied it.

The main point is that the tiger goes where the tiger wants to go. (It is a cat, after all.) The monkey is not about to argue with it, but she has a certain pride---so she makes up a story about why she wanted to go to wherever they both end up. The tiger represents the older parts of the brain that often make decisions for us and the monkey represents the more modern bits that govern things like conscious decision-making.

So far I'm well within the realm of orthodox psychology. But I'm going to take it one step further---simply because I think that this point seems obvious to me from self-reflection. (Philosophers are allowed to do this sort of thing as long as they freely admit that it is just speculation and are willing to be disabused of their idea if a good experiment proves it wrong.) I think that the tigers we ride aren't just artifacts of brain evolution. I also think that they are probably influenced by culture too. And what I call a person's "mythos" would be a key part of building a person's individual "tiger". 

&&&&

If we accept that a person uses motivated reasoning based upon their own inherited or personally-constructed mythological understanding of the world, then trying to reason them out of their crackpot behaviour is a waste of time. Instead, we need to stop the adoption of their nutty mythos in the first place. The problem with this idea is that it flies in the face of one of modern democracy's most cherished ideals: that everyone is entitled to their own personal belief system. 

I'm not suggesting that the state step in and force all people to accept the same worldview. That would be a totalitarian solution. But it might be possible to educate children so they understand the implications for life of the worldview they begin to see everything through. This would perhaps allow them the chance that they might "choose wisely" instead of just stumbling into something without understanding any of the implications.
 


I don't know much about Grey Owl, other than he was an Englishman who became so enamoured with an idealized myth about the First Nations of Canada that he moved to Northern Ontario and tried to totally adopt their lifestyle. I don't even know if it's true that he was accepted by members of the real First Nations, as the above video implies. But I do think that trying to live in harmony with nature was a damn sight better mythos than the British Imperialism and white superiority which a great many of his fellow citizens would have believed. 

In short---true or not---as the line from the "Heritage Minute" above says, people become what they dream. And it's important that we dream well. I would suggest that the people who refuse to wear masks and won't get vaccinated are people who have "dreamed poorly".

&&&&

That's enough for this week. Be nice to each other and don't get ahead of the health authorities as we slowly wake up out of this pandemic fever dream.

&&&&

Moreover I say unto you, the Climate Emergency must be dealt with!


 


Friday, September 20, 2019

Why Rationality is Important

This morning I had the unpleasant experience of spending a half hour listening to a Guelph candidate in the federal election. I won't go into details, but I haven't heard such a dense avalanche of total nonsense for a very, very long time. It got me thinking about how tremendously fragile a democracy can be.

People naively assume that all you need for a functioning democracy are relatively fair elections. But if you've really thought about it, that's the end result of developing several foundational cultural norms such as freedom of speech, the rule of law, a vigorous free press, and such. When I was listening to this Niagara of idiocy I got increasingly agitated because it was obvious that this fellow's campaign seems to be based on the principle of undermining and destroying at least one of them: the commitment to anchor policy on facts by using logic. 

&&&&

Most people don't think about the relationship between philosophy and science, and, democracy. But I believe that it wasn't just a coincidence that ancient Athenian participatory democracy flourished during the time of the great Greek philosophers, or, that modern liberal democracy came into being during the time of the European scientific enlightenment.

If you read Plato I think you get evidence of this relationship by considering the reoccurring theme of the disagreement between Socrates and the Sophists, or, between philosophy and rhetoric.

Philosophy is based on the premise that there are rules that one should follow in conversations that allow you to gain new information about the world. I think modern people often forget what a tremendously radical idea this really was. Just about every other society in the world at that time was based upon tradition, religious authority, and, brute force. People believed what they believed primarily because they had always believed it, because the priest told them, or, because if they said anything different---bad things would happen to them.

But something unprecedented happened in Greece---and Athens in particular. A space opened up in society that allowed people to ask the "unpleasant questions" that would usually result in getting the crap beaten out of you (or worse) anywhere else. As a result, the city state became a place where brilliant thinkers from all over the Mediterranean came to live. And they met and talked with each other, which allowed them to sharpen their insights.

I don't know much about ancient Athenian democracy, but it seems clear to me that there had to be a relationship between the philosophers and the assembly, because both are based on the idea that truth emerges from a conversation between people.

Plato. A Roman copy from a portrait made at the time of the philosopher's death.
Made by the sculptor Silanion. From the Boehringer Collection.
Image c/o the Wiki Commons

Unfortunately, at the same time that people like Heraclitus, Thales, Plato, Socrates, and, Aristotle were trying to work out the way to tell a good argument from a bad one, there was also a counter-current of people who were figuring out the best way to confuse the public in order to get what they wanted.

Probably the most infamous example was one of Socrates' students: Alcibiades. He sought to build his political career by promoting an unnecessary adventure that involved invading Sicily. The result was a catastrophic defeat that involved the annihilation of the cream of the Athenian military. It never recovered, and eventually Athens was conquered by Sparta. And the Athenian citizens lost their democracy.

Philosophy survived, primarily because it was excellent training for members of the elite who would then go on to study rhetoric. With democracy totally discredited---because it seemed to invariably result in demagogues like Alcibiades being put into power---the paragon of societies became Republics, like Rome. These were oligarchies:  societies where power resided in a wealthy elite. Politics and voting still occurred---which meant that rhetoric was considered an essential part of an ambitious man's education. But never again would butchers, bakers, stone masons, and, the guys who pulled an oar in a war galley have a say in how their society was run---at least until modern times.

&&&&

I generally ask individuals to support the "Back-Grounder" through Patreon and PayPal. But this time I'd like to ask businesses and community groups to consider purchasing an advertisement. If you provide me a graphic that I can incorporate into the body of the article (like the one that follows), it will be something that isn't taken out by an ad-blocker because it is permanently incorporated into the article.

This is an important point. I keep track of the number of hits on an article, and old articles are repeatedly looked at by lots of people. Unlike the newspapers which end up lining bird cages, washing windows, and, starting wood stoves---the articles in the "Back-Grounder" continue to be read months and years after they are published. 


The other thing to consider is that the readership of the "Back-Grounder" is concentrated on a very specific demographic: local, progressively-minded, engaged individuals. If you have a business or organization that is based on this slice of the population, these people are "the sea" that your business swims in. My readership is tiny compared to national blogs---but it consists only of people who would be of interest to you!

My rates are also affordable. I'm only asking a few bucks for an ad---and I'm quite open to things like in-store credits and barter. So why not give the Back-Grounder a try? You can email me at: thecloudwalkingowl@gmail.com .



&&&&

Liberal democracy (the modern form) arose during a similar period of philosophical exuberance. Only the driver for this wasn't logic, but rather science. The European enlightenment was driven by the "new learning" that came from people like Galileo, Newton, and so on. The tremendous growth in human knowledge that grew out of the scientific method emboldened philosophers to look at their societies in much the same way that the experimental method had dramatically changed people's understanding of astronomy, physics, medicine, chemistry, and so on.

These people ceased to look towards some divine basis for government and were instead "empiricists". This was the idea that human society could be studied just like any other part of the world around us. And that we could use the insights that arise from that investigation could be used to improve how we make collective decisions.

John Locke. Line drawing by Crovonrosso.
Image c/o the Wiki Commons.

One of the great fathers of Enlightenment political theory was John Locke who said
"whatever I write, as soon as I discover it not to be true, my hand shall be the forwardest to throw it into the fire." 
This is totally at odds with rhetoric, which is used not to find the truth, but rather to "score points", convince people, and, amass power.

&&&&

This gets me back to the noxious individual I had to listen to this morning. I suspect that he genuinely believes what he said. But if he does, it's because he's expended very little effort in trying to find out if what he says is actually true. That is especially pathetic because we live currently live in an age when it is so incredibly easy for a person to find the facts about most contentious issues.

Just to give one tiny example. When asked about whether or not his party is in favour of the pipeline to the West coast, our stalwart candidate said "Alberta is the engine driving the Canadian economy". I'm not suggesting that he invented this idea, but he was certainly helping to spread it. And this is something that it is very easy to "truth-test". It took me about a minute to use Google to look up the Gross Domestic Product of Ontario ($728 billion), Quebec ($338 billion) and Alberta ($335 billion) in 2018. Indeed adding together all the numbers for all the provinces and territories, it turns out that the Alberta GDP only comes to about 17% of the total Canadian economy.  So in actual fact Alberta isn't "the engine driving the Canadian economy" by any stretch of the imagination---. (Repeating this statement over and over and over and over again simply doesn't make it so.) 

The problem with this guy isn't that he's wrong. It's that if you point out that he is wrong, he won't change what he says. He certainly won't be like John Locke and "be the forwardest to throw it into the fire". That's because he isn't interested in finding the truth, but rather in pushing his agenda.

&&&&

And that's tremendously dangerous in a democracy. If enough politicians, journalists, and, voters stop caring about whether something a politician says is actually true, then we start edging towards the bad old world where everything gets decided on the basis of money and brute force.

That's the thing about democracy. All societies have to figure out how how to make decisions and divide up scarce resources. Throughout most of human history this has been done through tradition or brute force. What is unique about both ancient Athens and modern liberal democracies like Canada is that---at least in principle---they do it by having an honest and open debate between different points of view. The idea is that this conversation is the best way for truth to assert itself and that the general opinion of the mass of citizens usually comes to---if not the best, at least a "good enough" decision.

Unfortunately, this isn't always the case. Sometimes people temporarily lose their way and become overwhelmed by their emotions---both individually and collectively. When they do, fast-talking, "slick Willies" can use rhetoric to bamboozle them into voting against their best interests. That's how ancient Athens ended up sending their fleet off to it's destruction. It's also how the people of Germany pissed-away the Weimar Republic. It's also how Canada could sleep walk its way into a climate catastrophe.

It looks to me---from what I've seen in the last decade or so---that many politicians are trying transition from making the best logical, evidence-based argument to instead creating rhetorical appeals to people's emotions. That's why truth seems to be so much less important than "truthiness" today. It's also why the lies seem so much more brazen. People often aren't ashamed when you catch them fibbing---and many just ignore you if you point out an error. They just keep repeating the same bullshit over and over again, because telling bullshit is what they are all about.

The problem with emotions is that they are dangerous beasts. They need to be tamed and kept under control. We've seen where the politics of emotions can lead people---and it's a dark, dark place. That's what made the 20th century the time of enormous wars. Let's hope that we can collectively step back from this time of delusional politics and find some "new enlightenment" that can inform our political institutions.

&&&&

Furthermore, I say onto you the Climate Emergency must be dealt with!